A quest for Jimi Hendrix’s faster-playing style solutions

New mechanical discovery, medium confidence level: Jimi’s pull-off technique at least included what I’d call a “flick-off” motion of his fretting finger.

I, and (I’d expect) most people, tend to perform pull-offs with a slight curling action of the fretting finger. In close-up video of Jimi performing a quick repeating five-note motif here ( https://youtu.be/EDaYPV7lrkY?si=E4Cz27ZKmjMyBhzu&t=386 ) we can see that the 8-5 fretting sequence on the high e string uses his ring finger with a distinct extension motion as it leaves the eighth fret.

These notes ARE picked, not pure legato, and as such don’t demonstrate clearly that he used this “pushing/flicking” extension motion for pure pull-offs. But I think it’s very likely that this is responsible for many of the quick apparent “micro-bends” in his faster playing, e.g. throughout the fills in Red House. This type of movement would also just be a totally natural consequence of small bluesy bends on the “upper floor” of any given pentatonic box.

I’d bet this movement is already intuitively familiar to anybody who’s ever learned a Chuck Berry riff.

I also think Jimi almost definitely used the more common “finger curl”-type pull-offs too, and may have preferred them. But now that I’ve spotted the extension pull-offs, I’m going to keep an eye out for his tendencies as to what contexts he uses that movement for.

Newest update: I’ve been looking very closely at the studio-recorded version of “Red House” as a study in Hendrix’s pentatonic sweeping. There are several examples of it throughout, and with a very careful ear and lots of slowed-down listening, I’ve been able to discern some fine details in a few of the quicker licks.

Hendrix would use sweeping in pentatonic lead playing in either the ascending or descending direction, much like what Frank Gambale later became famous for doing. This necessitates some amount of two-way pickslanting, but Hendrix’s primary pickslant was downward, with a USX motion. This raises the question of “where does he place the escaped pickstroke within a sequence that includes sweeping?” And the answer is, unsurprisingly, “it depends.” He situationally incorporates DBX motions at medium-to-fast speeds, while leaning more heavily on two-way pickslanting / economy picking / sweeping for his fastest phrases.

Since Hendrix’s primary alternate picking motion was USX, he had to “force the upstroke” on phrases that begin with a single note on the high e string (a common phrase element of his). In Red House, the fill at 0:54 is one example of when he uses a double-escaped pick motion to play a quick (but not lightning-fast) pentatonic fill, focused mostly on a syncopated against-the-beat feel, until he abruptly “falls off” the phrase at the end with normal USX alternate picking.

On the other hand, the fast lick he plays at 1:39 is a bit more intense, and it takes advantage of pure economy sweep picking in a really cool way:

eb|-------------d7-----------d9–u7----------------------------------------
Bb|----------d7----u10-d7---------u7–d10^(12)-----------------------
Gb|–d9^(11)---------------------------------------------------------------
Db|---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ab|---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eb|---------------------------------------------------------------------------

How awesome is that? Initial ascending “Chuck Berry riff” sweep, reverse pick outside the strings, upstroke through the B string, then the pick stays buried for the rest of the riff. That ninth (both fret and scale degree) on the high e string is a staple of his faster pentatonic soloing, and infrequently appears in his pentatonic soloing at slow tempos. With his fretting hand, that note is played with the middle finger, while the tenth-fret note on the B string is played with the ring finger.

In Homer’s epic poetry, the poet gives nicknames (“epithets”) to his characters: “swift-footed Achilles,” “thunderous Zeus,” etc. Those epithets both help characterize his heroes and gods, but also serve the vital function of making the meter of the poem line up correctly, adding the appropriate number of syllables to each name to make the poem’s rhythm flow. I think with Jimi’s use of the ninth in his pentatonic playing, we’re seeing a similar synergy of artistic color and functional utility: adding that note into fast playing allows him to use his middle finger when his ring finger is otherwise occupied, adds a note to the high e string to facilitate economy-picking turnarounds, AND gives the lick a bright-voiced wistful emotional tinge. I love this man’s playing so much. It’s a real joy to get to dig so deeply into this music, and get some insight into the hands and mind and soul that made it.

The first half of that, that was my big takeaway from the video that’s now down - you could nitpick “swept” vs “raked” but it was definitely connected downstrokes, whereas I was coming at this stuff more from a SRV angle, sort of a crosspicking/hybrid mashup (I actually don’t know if he used hybrid picking, but I distinctly remember reading that he’d often “pop” the top note of that Chuck Berry style rick with one of his fingers, so I think that’s just hiow I learned it). I

It has a VERY different sound - much slinkier with Jimi’s approach, so I’m trying to learn it both ways. For bonus points, SRV does a damned good Jimi impression on, I think, Blues at Sunrise on the SRV/Albert King In Session album, and I’d LOVE to see how he picks it when he’s doing his Jimi thing.

1 Like

New (small) observation today, from a hand closeup at his Royal Albert Hall (2/24/69) performance: in a sequence where Jimi is bending fret 9 on the G string while holding fret 10 on the B string, he holds the B string note with his pinkie but still bends fret 9 on G with his middle finger. His ring finger is floating unused between the two. It’s a micro-detail, but it’s interesting how strong his preference for middle finger bends on the G string seems to have been.

1 Like

Just had my mind blown by a realization while in a deep dive on “Red House”–I was looking at which pentatonic positions Hendrix preferred when playing higher notes on the neck, and noticed he never seemed to use the highest frets… and then I remembered: the cutaway on his strat was on the wrong side of the fretboard. I had previously noticed this, but it didn’t occur to me in the context of his preferred high-note pentatonics, but sure enough: the highest easily-accessible fret from the wrong side of an opposite-handed strat cutaway is right around fret 19, which is the fret he does a fast slide up to hit near the end of the Red House solo. For Hendrix, that slide would have been auto-limited by the shape of the body of his guitar.

Then, just because I felt that idea leading me down a line of thought, I took my own strat and flipped it over in my lap as if I were playing it opposite-handed. This is what REALLY blew my mind: because the body contour isn’t symmetrical either, sitting with a strat flipped in your lap shifts the position of the guitar in a way that EXACTLY enables Hendrix’s hand positions. The whole guitar is shifted relatively closer to your picking hand and away from your fretting hand by the slightly higher contour curve on the non-pickguard side. This means your picking arm has to wrap further around the body to reach the strings comfortably, making it impractical to rest your wrist on the bridge, but making Hendrix’s supinated, trailing-edge picking position really convenient and easy. And because the fretboard is now shifted relatively inside across the front of your body, the ultra-pronated, thumb-wrapped fretting hand position fits perfectly across most of the accessible fretboard.

What a crazy butterfly effect! The unique playing mechanics Jimi used giving him access to unique musical vocabulary, and those mechanics themselves suggested for him by the location of the body contour on the wrong side of a Stratocaster. I guess I need to finally start shopping for a lefty strat.

3 Likes

Have you noticed any difference in Jimi’s playing from his Gibson era? Those go the opposite direction in terms of ergonomics as they allow even better access than a Strat in normal position.

3 Likes

I haven’t noticed any explicit differences, although I do want to go back and double-check some footage to see if anything appreciably changes. But the main thrust of my current hypothesis is that the body contour ergonomics of the reversed strat influenced the development of some of Hendrix’s mechanical strategies, and that he then (likely) implemented those same strategies even in situations where the ergonomic constraints no longer applied—like when playing a Gibson, or even playing his strats standing up.

But who knows? There’s a whole wealth of knowledge still to be found in his style, and I may learn more tomorrow that completely flips that. I’ll definitely be looking at it!

3 Likes