I went through the whole thing. They all were very uncomfortable lol! There were 1 or 2 I simply couldn’t play, at least at the exact location specified. I can’t imagine switching to these chords at the drop of a hat like he did.
I remember when I was studying classical guitar, the chord I could not physically do (at first, it isn’t difficult for me at all now) was this one:
The big stretch right at 1:02
When my instructor presented me with this piece, my hands would not physically reach no matter what twists and turns I made with my hand, wrist, elbow or shoulder. But, I got it. So that makes me think with some work I could get a little better with the Holdsworth chords. After all, I’ve been not playing classical for the past 2 or 3 years so my left hand finger independence (and flexibility) is a little rusty (i.e. out of practice, that is not a reference to Mr. Cooley). But these Holdsworth chords are absolutely more challenging than the chords featured in most of the hardest classical pieces I’ve played. One sneaky challenge in the classical pieces, that I don’t know if an equivalent exists or not in Holdsworth’s world, is that we typically would hold chords like this while removing/changing fingers that followed a melody or harmony change. Sometimes those changes were harder than landing the chord to begin with.
But back on topic, I can’t think of another player with this level of innovation. Who did he have to look up to so that he could form this vocabulary? I know for decades prior to him there were ‘challenging’ chord melody arrangements in the jazz guitar world, but Holdsworth dials that up to 11. Is it possible for anyone to go beyond this? We are up against some very real physical limitations. And I think this stuff is off the table for individuals with smaller hands.