First off… you’ve got awesome fretting skills. Very impressed. I just tried it as well… and I couldn’t transition as well as you.
Thank you! Yeah like a lot of folks, lefty is in better shape than righty.
As far as the X-picking vs eco-picking… there’s no question that more guitarists know the latter. And that’s probably because it takes 10x longer to learn the former. It took me a year to convert to double-escaping, and then another year to fix my tracking for the 1NPS stuff. That’s quite a commitment of time. (I’m guessing others can probably learn it quicker than me.) But once you get passed the initial learning curve… it makes things easier in almost every area of playing. I’ve gone back and tried all the old stuff I couldn’t play… and suddenly now its playable.
But I don’t know how you would approach a student who wants to learn this kinda thing. Maybe if they already have a bit of a double-escaped stroke… it might be worth it for them to fine-tune it. Otherwise… I guess econo-picking is probably the way.
Here’s how I approach it as a teacher, and I’d actually be interested in feedback from @Troy, yourself, others.
And I’m really transparent with my students about this:
I, me, Jake, I have had a lot of success with pick slanting, hybrid, etc, re-arranging fingerings of things to make them more accessible for my right hand bag of tricks. It’s all stuff I’ve worked on a lot and I feel good about what I can do with the techniques. Cross picking, I personally have devoted a tiny bit of time to it and wasn’t making a lot of headway so I decided to put it on the back burner for now but definitely want to revisit it.
I feel like I see and have heard of a lot of players re-learning slanting techniques (and avoiding the most difficult picking motions for non-crosspickers) and having a lot of success with it, but to this day I haven’t seen a ton of people learning crosspicking for the first time in their lives and then developing abilities to really blaze with it.
I see clearly what Troy has developed for himself with the technique, and I also see that Troy and others are continually trying to refine how to teach and explain the technique.
So I tell students what I have had success with, and what I have seen other people have success with - not just “Batio does it this way” but rather instances of people who struggled for a long time and then found solutions. When I tell them about cross picking I basically say I think it might wind up being the answer to a lot of picking problems, but A. I personally don’t know how to do it at a high level B. I don’t know a lot of examples of people who have changed their pick style to this and had a lot of success with it C. I don’t know of a consistently successful method of teaching the technique, and I certainly am in no position to develop my own…seeing as I can’t even do it, hah!
So I basically have a set of processes I use with them to develop their vocabulary and get their stuff up to tempo and I’m clear with them about all this and invite them to explore crosspicking, but that I won’t personally be able to help them with it at this time.
That seem fair?
I’m really hopeful that in, say, five years, this won’t be the case, at least for the guitar community in general if not for my own teaching and playing.