Handedness in guitar playing

Why is picking with your right hand considered “righty”? Why isn’t fretting with your right hand considered “righty”? After all, aren’t fretting motions pretty complicated?

That being said, I’m right-handed and not ambidextrous and I don’t think of myself as being limited fretting-wise. I don’t feel like I’m using my weaker hand, like I do when trying to write lefty. If there is any impact to fretting with my left hand instead of my right hand, I can’t tell what it is.

Steve Morse, Michael Angelo Batio, and (I think!) Eddie Van Halen are/were all left-handed players who pick righty. It goes without saying that these are some of the best pickers of all time.

In short, what impact does handedness have on guitar skill, and why should anyone even think about it at all?

2 Likes

Hi, I’m left handed, allegedly not naturally though, but who knows, my fretting hand feels ok although I have huge and thin hands and it feels sometimes cumbersome, BUT my picking hand (left hand) is definitely burdened with some flaws compared to my right hand (I somtimes try to pick using my right hand), so first of all I can tremolo pick fast with my right hand, and holding a pick feels much much more comfortable, plus the hand is neither slanted down nor up, just perfect, plus the dynamics are much better/stronger, and stable, there is one big problem when I try to pick with my right hand, and it is I have to fret with my left hand, and this is a tragedy

While it doesn’t answer the handedness question definitively, Eddie signed autographs with his right hand.

Edit: Further, during the era he went to school, it wasn’t unheard of for kids to be “forced” to learn to write with their right hand, even if they were “naturally” left-handed.

To add onto this, and with the caveat that I don’t know how much it matters, I do know a couple lefties who intentionally learned to play rightie, just because it was easier to get right handed guitars.

1 Like

I’m not saying I know for sure, it’s just what I saw mentioned but I can no longer recall where. I think someone might have mentioned it in a YouTube or Instagram comment recently.

The other two guys though, they’ve both mentioned it for sure. I’m sure there are other famous lefties who pick righty.

As I’ve mentioned, I’ve also tried picking lefty recently and it’s clear it would work. Interestingly, it was totally just wrist motion, with zero forearm, like perfectly still. Which is not how my motions looked right handed initially.

Well that just makes plenty of sense!

I’m left handed, learnt on a standard guitar. That said, I STILL instinctively air guitar the reverse (left hand picking) after all these years.

When I’m visualizing stuff I do righty, but when I hear a tune I love come on I always find myself doing a big Pete Townsend pick with my left hand and fretting a nice big a chord with my right lol.

I’m lefty and I play “lefty” - I basically chose a “lefty” guitar was because I always played a “lefty” air guitar for some reason and it felt more natural. I wonder, if we asked people who don’t play guitar, to mimic playing, would there be a correlation between their handedness and the way they air play? Perhaps if one way feels more natural for a beginner, then that’s a good enough reason to go with that way given the lack of data on the impact.

Edit: ninja’d by @MikeHendrycks on the topic of air guitar, interesting!

1 Like

Fascinating!! I wonder what causes that… :face_with_monocle:

To address the original question, I wonder if it’s related to the fact that the picking hand is responsible for the actual generation of the sound, while the fretting hand is responsible for more subtle details like note selection. If we reduce the goal of guitar playing to extremely simple terms, it could be described as something like, ‘making sounds come out of the guitar’. In which case, it is the picking hand doing the ‘driving’. From a purely psychological perspective, we tend to prefer perform new tasks with our dominant hand, and to use our non-dominant hand as a ‘helper’ when necessary. The task of the picking hand is more energetic, uses larger motions, and is more directly responsible for the action that results in sound, while the fretting hand tasks use smaller motions and is responsible for finer details of the sound.

Hammer-ons and pull-offs are performed with the fretting hand, but those are more advanced techniques that are not usually learned until well after picking is learned and the choice of which hand to use for picking has already been made. The first chord we play isn’t done in time. It usually involves us forcing our fretting fingers into place, holding them there, and then ‘playing’ the chord with the picking hand. Both hands are working, but the result doesn’t happen until the picking hand does its job.

In the long run, it seems that either choice can ultimately work. But handedness issues are usually resolved right when we begin the journey of learning, so maybe it just makes the early stages slightly easier, if only psychologically, to allow our dominant hand to drive the activity.

If you were going to learn the xylophone, which hand would you choose to strike the first note?

3 Likes

I can’t say much scientifically or anatomically except for the lack of data - and as someone who has taught a lot of absolute beginners, I occasionally get the ‘which guitar to buy’ question.

I’ve tried looking up if anyone has anything solid on this, but most of the arguments for lefties being better off playing lefty guitar don’t seem to have much substance. Interestingly, in classical stringed instruments, I believe left handed/backwards instruments were pretty much not a thing - this is from memory of researching it a bit, I could be wrong, but I think historically there were not ‘left handed’ violins, in orchestras, etc.

So I always told the parents simply “I don’t know” but also that there wasn’t any research of evidence that their left handed child would be at a disadvantage to play a ‘right handed’ guitar. And that if they began playing the conventional righty guitars, then they’d have many more options for future guitars to buy or play, being over a friend’s house who plays picking up their guitar, etc.

It’s a slight, but tangible, disadvantage to need a specialized guitar to play, as guitars are everywhere, easy to find, etc. It’s an unknown and only hypothetical/theoretical disadvantage for someone to learn on a ‘wrong hand’ guitar.

In a few decades teaching full time, I think I’ve only had 2 or 3 students that played left handed guitars!

Did you just flip over your guitar? I just tried that too (flipping it over) and I think due to the lack of a forearm contour (at least on strats) the elbow can’t go behind the guitar body. Maybe that somehow facilitates wrist motion?

I remember hearing in the pickslanting primer tutorials that the contour might cause the elbow to be behind the guitar body - which creates the need of dialing wrist flexion.

Maybe also throughout daily life the usual motions you did with your right hands are different, hence causing different motions to be the first motion path you stumble upon.

And as for the handedness issue, I am a lefty that plays standard. I feel no difference whatsoever, it is just more convenient for me to buy/play guitars :smiley:

My theory is that when these stringed instruments were first developing, the dominant hand was doing the fingerpicking - the complicated bit. But with electric guitars I don’t think there is much of a difference.

I did just flip it over, but this was on the two Duo-Sonics which are the guitars I have at home here, and they’re not contoured. This kind of flat body with a real low bridge is a simple design for learning certain picking motions like wrist motion. I can rest right on the body and still reach all strings. A Telecaster would probably be similar as a learning tool.

I’m cautious about saying one type of instrument is “easier” than another because it could just be trial and error, sample size of one. But that has been my experience thus far with this style bodies.

Lefty checking in who plays righty - I honestly didn’t know when I started playing guitar that left handed people played guitar the other way, I just assumed everyone picked with their right and fretted with their left because all the guitars I had ever seen were made that way. Kinda glad for that mistake as it gives me a lot more options and I can pick up any guitar and play it. Although it would be cool to be like Eric Gales and just play a right handed guitar upside down :upside_down_face:

I gave my answer to this question a few posts up, but having thought about it overnight I’ve decided I can do a little better.

My original answer was essentially this: in complex tasks where the hands have different functions, the dominant hand will have a tendency to take the job that ‘actuates’ the task while the non-dominant hand will tend to perform ‘helper’ functions. Thus the fretting hand prepares the note, and the picking hand ‘plays’ the note. As an analogy, the picking hand drives, while the fretting hand steers. I still think this is roughly accurate.

But I think there is a more interesting approach: tool use. The most basic hand tools are used for striking or cutting. Usually the dominant hand will hold the tool and perform the striking or cutting, and the non-dominant hand will hold and manipulate the object being cut or struck. Examples: hammer and nails, saw and board, knife and steak. Slightly more advanced tools follow a similar pattern: screwdrivers, hand drills, files, sandpaper, pencil, computer mouse, laser pointer, etc. The untrained fighter will prefer to throw punches with his or her dominant hand. A novice shooter will prefer to pull the trigger with their dominant hand and use the non-dominant hand to support the weapon. Baseball players generally catch the ball (object manipulation with minimal motion size) with their non-dominant hand and throw the ball (i.e. apply force) with their dominant hand.

This suggests an evolutionary aspect to handedness in guitar playing: Maybe as our ancestors developed the ability to create and use tools that improved their survival and reproduction rate, they developed a genetic tendency to specialize the usage of their hands (via specialization of the brain hemispheres). Maybe handedness makes tool usage more intuitive and gives an evolutionary advantage to individuals that need to crack nuts, cut meat, fish for ants, throw spears, etc. Studies have shown that when chimpanzees use tools or throw poop at strangers, they will preferentially use their dominant hands, which is predominantly (~70% of those studied) their right hand.

Picking a guitar is performed by striking, and often resembles a cutting motion (so does bowing a violin, etc.) So if we think of the guitar as a complex percussion instrument, it kind of makes sense that we would manipulate the object with our non-dominant hand and apply the striking/cutting force with our dominant hand. The pick is itself a tool, so it also makes sense that we would hold that tool with our dominant hand.

I admit this is all pretty unsubstantiated conjecture, but I find it convincing, and welcome counter-arguments.

6 Likes

I like the tool use analogy! And the evolutionary tie-in. Cool insight, it certainly seems plausible to me that tool use and musical skills share some type of physiological and evolutionary similarities.

I will add some potentially useless anecdotal advice to this conversation -

There are no left handed pianos. Or saxophones or trombones or tubas or marimbas or Dells (for DJs lol). Pianists and percussionists do awfully complicated things with both hands. Why do guitarists (almost exclusively?) get a south paw instrument?

That being said, my pick and strings feel like they are made of helium when flip the guitar around.

I don’t think the question is whether you can learn to do complicated things with either hand. The question is, when the functions of each hand are not identical, and one has a larger motion, higher strength requirement, or a more crucial timing function, which hand will you choose for that function? Yes, in the long run you could almost certainly learn either way, but in the very early stages you will make faster progress if you choose your dominant hand for this function. In my experience, people who quit an instrument often quit early, so maybe getting over that initial hump is easier if you follow the natural preferences of your brain wiring.

On a piano, a keyed woodwind (saxophone, clarinet, etc.), and most percussion instruments (marimbas, etc.) both hands do the same job. There is no reason to reverse the instrument if both hands have the same function.

For many wind instruments with asymmetric functionality, like trumpet, french horn, tuba, or trombone, it is generally the right hand that performs the more energetic action, while the left hand often just holds the instrument, which conforms to the fact that 90% of humans are right-handed. On these instruments the timing is provided by the breath, not the hands, so the choice of which hand to use may be less crucial.

Drum kits are designed for asymmetric functionality, and most kits are set up so that the right foot plays the kick, the right hand plays the hi hat and the left hand plays the snare. Thus the dominant hand keeps time, and most often hits 4 times for every left hand hit. Left handed drummers can easily set their kits up backwards, but doing so makes them less able to sit in with a band on someone else’s kit, which is pretty common for drummers, especially at jam sessions. So, like guitar players, many drummers learn to play right-handed.

There are left-handed violins, but if you want to play in an orchestra, you’ll need to play right-handed so you and your neighbor don’t smack your bows together. Plus it ruins the visual aesthetic of the string section to have one or two people bowing the opposite direction as everyone else. In practice, it is nearly impossible to become a classical performer playing a bowed instrument left-handed. In a smaller, non-classical band, it’s not so much of a problem, but most string players are not self-taught, and most violin (etc.) teachers were classically taught themselves, so most violinists end up playing right-handed.

So guitar players are the special case because the guitar requires asymmetric functionality in the hands, and because guitar instruction is not predominantly classical anymore, not to mention that many rock guitarists are initially self-taught. A left-handed guitarist is free to choose which way to learn, and the only major argument against appeasing the preferences of your brain wiring is the availability of instrument to buy or borrow.

1 Like

Very interesting way of thinking about this. Honestly, I’ve always wondered how this plays out myself - it would intuitively make sense that the dominant hand would be given the most complex task when accomplishing a task, yet from a dexterity standpoint, fretting is a lot more complicated and intricate than picking is, so I’ve found myself wondering on, well, at least a couple occasions, why it is that almost all right handed guitarists use their right hand for picking.

The framework of tool use, and the right hand doing more cutting and striking tasks while the left hand doing some often fairly dexterous stuff of its own to support the cutting and striking, is a very interesting one.

All I’m gonna say is I can’t even brush my teeth with my non-dominant hand without poking out my eye - I can’t imagine trying to pick with it…

I might give it a go though for kicks.

1 Like