I bought the Rusty archive as soon as it came out. Can confirm, he swipes both at top speed and the more “moderate” stuff (putting “moderate” in quotes here to feel better about myself 
).
1 Like
I think we need to differentiate between the kind accidental contact that occurs in everyone’s
playing and the sort of systematic swiping that is used by people like Batio and Jorge Strunz. I don’t think Rusty is a systematic swiper, where he uses it specifically on certain string changes all the time, as a “technique”. It’s a little more complicated than that.
Alternatively, what you will also see, is that he will often pick an even number of notes per string while fretting an odd number. So the picking “works out”, even though it doesn’t line up strictly with what is going on in the left hand. In other words, it’s not like Yngwie where you have a certain number of picked notes and then a single legato note. When Rusty does a lot of these odd number patterns, there is no specific “legato note”. It’s just wherever it lines up, and it’s a little different every time.
You could call this “unsynchronized” but I don’t think that adequately explains what’s going on. I think he actually can tell by feel that the picking needs to be even, and he is choosing the closest match of even numbered pickstrokes to whatever he is fretting. It’s not 100% consistent and sure you will probably see swiping here and there. But the number of times you will see an actual even number of notes, uwps-style, where the last note is a downstroke, means I think there is a sort of formula at work.
The resulting sound is somewhere between picking and legato, you may like it or not. I think it’s cool. I can’t do it that’s for sure. It’s also impossible to notate in tablature. Picking six notes per string while fretting seven. That’s what it is, transcribe it as you like!
Rusty may be coming in soon, we’re trying to set that up.
6 Likes
I don’t mean to sound too confrontational here, and I haven’t looked at these clips in a while, but what would you call his descending outside string changes then? I remember seeing pretty systematic swiping here without extra pickstrokes. There’s also an instance of him playing the PG-lick out there on the internet using what looks to me like his top-speed mechanic and the swiping seems pretty audible to me, let me see if I can find it (2:30 or so here):
Addendum: Hasn’t the sort of “accidental contact” you mention always been referred to here as swiping before? Or are you talking about changing what we mean when we say “swiping?”
1 Like
lol, well it seems like either way the term will seem to have a negative connotation to it. Thanks for the info. I will surely check the Rusty stuff out whenever it is put up.
The reason I asked is, I find myself acquainted with quite a few alternate pickers that design their playing around keeping the pick strokes even. But they do swipe if they get caught on a stroke that would require any rotation.
What I am calling swipers is any player that will swipe, instead of rotating, out of a trapped pick stroke anytime the situation arises… So if they are good, they of course would avoid a trapped pick stroke. I feel that there are A LOT of players like this.
1 Like
This is what I was figuring Eric… I think Paul Gilbert swipes that lick in Intense Rock if I’m not mistaken. 
No confrontation taken!
What I’m describing definitely happens in his playing, and I’m pretty sure there are examples of it in the “Code Archive” clips if you still have those. I’m not saying he does this exclusively on every clip, but I am saying it happens and it explains why his playing sometimes has a kind of legato sound to it even when he is picking continuously. Rusty was the first person we ever filmed, so I’ve seen this with every version of the camera that we’ve ever built. I had no idea what I was seeing at first and it wasn’t until much later that I realized what was happening.
Note also that he has a few different techniques and what we’re describing here is his elbow hyper picking technique. What you’re calling “moderate” mode is his more traditional (if we can call it that) two-way pickslanting technique. In that technique, he is making the motions to escape when necessary. He may have occasional string contact but it’s the kind of accidental contact that happens in everyone’s playing.
And yes, Rusty’s ‘moderate’ mode is probably fast enough for most people! I know he has hung his hat on the elbow technique, in a sense, even though it is not as traditionally accurate as his 2wps approach.
That may be the case, but again, I’m not saying this is systematic in the sense that he simply doesn’t bother escaping and hits all strings at all times, as a standardized approach, the way Jorge does. And he doesn’t even really selectively but consistently hit certain strings the way Batio does. He may do bits of those in various cases, but what he does do that none of the others players appear to do is the odd/even thing. And it happens often enough that I don’t think it’s accidental.
I have some footage of him playing the PG lick, and what is actually happening is interesting and changes whether he is doing the inside or outside version of it. In one of them, I think it’s the outside version, he actually does what I call “displacement”, which I’ve talked about a little bit here:
In other words, I think the general thing I get from his playing is that he can tell by feel that the pickstrokes need to be on certain strings to go fast and actively changes up the picking structure to accomodate that, even when it doesn’t strictly match what is going on in the left hand.
2 Likes
I would resist the temptation to think this. As an example, Strunz and Farah just put out their latest album, and it contains the intro jam they played during our interview. It’s now an official tune called “Butterfly’s Wing”, and you can listen to the studio version of it right on their home page, here:
That’s Jorge on lead for most of that song. Knowing what we now know about his technique, I have to say, it really is pretty amazing how damn good this sounds. Calling that a “mistake” really overlooks the fact of how well this can actually be done if you really want to. And I don’t even completely understand how he’s getting it so silent. A capella, in the room, it’s more audible. But even then you won’t hear it on every string change. And he is the most extensive user of it of anyone we have interviewed, and that includes Rusty.
More generally, again, if we really want to understand how things work out there in the world, I think it’s worth making a distinction between players who have taken this concept and baked into their technique in a repeatable way, versus those players like me - and I will certainly put myself in that category - who do it occasionally as more of a mistake.
Even in the mistake category, you will have players who will bonk an open string so hard that you’ll hear it from a mile away. And then there are those who will hit surrounding strings and you will never hear it or even it know it is happening without the kind of close-up footage that we film.
5 Likes
As a great example of Rusty’s two-way pickslanting technique, check this out:
I remember that when he played this, he didn’t think it was all that good, and said something to the effect of how come I can’t do this as fast as the other lines? I on the other hand thought it was great.
I still think this speaks volumes as to the guy’s innate ability to learn complicated mechanics intuitively. Swiping or not, and I’m sure there’s some of it here, he is clearly making the “correct” escape motions and the line sounds great. Not too many people can play this line or for that matter even know how it should be played.
And much of his sweeping is unassailable. The arpeggio sequence at :35 of this clip is just straight up cool, in my book. I don’t have shredcam footage of it but I love the writing and it sounds clean to me. And the three-string min7 arpeggio at 1:30 is about as fast and accurate as I think sweeping can really be done:
5 Likes
Now this kicks ass man. 
And finally here’s that arpeggio sequence dropped into Logic and lined up with a click:
That’s 190bpm sextuplets, or about 285bpm sixteenths. I know this is sweeping, but this isn’t just slamming across all six strings, once, as fast as you can strum. These are repeated synchronized fretting movements. In the slow motion version of this from the clip above, you can see that the two-way pickslanting of the sweep, and the synchronization, is all on point. And it sounds like it.
Why do I care? Well I just think Rusty gets a bad rap and I know some of that boils down to creative choices and matters of taste. And trying to change anyone’s mind on that is swimming upstream. But Rusty is a legit natural when it comes to the range of mechanical abilities he has, as much as any of the players we have interviewed.
4 Likes
I think this is not totally accurate. The discovery here of “unsynchronized” picking is really just a polyrhythm in fretted notes vs. pick strokes (in this case a 7:6 polyrhythm). Keyboardists have had to contend with these tricky patterns in 2 hands for centuries, luckily they have 2 staves to work with in writing two separate rhythmic parts.
Chopin gives 6:4 and 6:5 polyrhythms in the Etude Op. 25 no. 1:
In most tab/notation software, pick strokes are defined in relation to a specific note, so you’re correct that there isn’t a practical way to notate a polyrhythm in notes / pick strokes. Here’s an inelegant solution:
The fundamental musical concept here is pretty straightforward. You could show it on paper easily, but would anybody know how to read it?
More generally, why would you do it? This is essentially, a “mistake”, unless we decide that we like the unsynchronized sound and want to emulate its randomness intentionally. Which someone might! I’m not saying you never would. I am a product of my times, I can think only in the box I was born in. 
2 Likes
Well, you’ve pointed out that this is not a “mistake”, but a systematic mechanic in Rusty and Marshall Harrison’s playing:
Apparently these dudes like the sound or feel of the mechanic enough (at a subconscious level, apparently) to use it - and the notation kind of makes more sense then a random hammer/pulloff to represent it as accurately as possible.
Yes, for sure, it’s the body figuring out a way to play the line, which is cool from a motor learning perspective. But it’s probably still not what they’re “intending”, if you want to think of it that way. I think most players would probably still take it personally at some level if you were like, hey dude, the picking doesn’t really match up to the fretting. It’s always weird for me to discuss this topic because as much as I like knowing that things exist in the world, I also want to be sensitive to the players who have taken their time to meet with us.
4 Likes
I just hope Rusty and Marshall take some more time to meet with y’all soon
I have always played the fast part of the Highway Star solo picking 16th notes while making triplets with the left hand.
Very cool effect.
Do you mean hemiola?
1 Like
It’s 2020 and still no traces of Rusty Cooley. I am wondering what happened to his interview/videos. Forum search gave the “Introducing the Code Archive”, but link to his page (https://troygrady.com/codearchive/rusty/) returns 404 page not found.
Bumping this in hopes of update on Rusty Cooley materials that are alluded to in this thread
Bump again. He is incredible.