Made an account just to comment on this. I’ve got a lot of helpful information on who is actually behind this, and AJGA has been around for a while so I figured a lot of people have been taken advantage of at this point. This will continue until more people are aware.
Like OP I am also a huge Andy James fan, and I’ve had the opportunity to talk to him about who is actually behind the site. AJ has said he left the site around the time he joined 5FDP, so he actually doesn’t know what’s going on with the site anymore.
I’m sure Andy is at least somewhat aware of what’s going on. It is infinitely more likely that the extent of AJ’s involvement is more like he just kind of turns a blind eye to it, since he is legally safe because he is no longer involved with the site (this is just according to him and under the assumption he wasn’t lying to me). It’s still not right but at least the situation is more understandable in that context.
For anyone in the future with problems with AJGA, get in touch with PayPal and make a case in Resolution Centre, they have these situations covered as part of Buyer Protection. Make sure you do it within 6 months of any erroneous charge/funny business.