What Guitar Should I Buy?

I must find a new electric guitar that meets my criteria for a reasonable price. Custom guitars run about $5000. That’s too much. Factory guitars are too factory and don’t fit me well. I want light, comfortable, and very sturdy. But I don’t know… What to get?

Thinking…
Rhoads v because of how it balances for standing playing and light.

Maple neck thru for sustain.

Mahogany body, chambered top wing.

Headless for weight and balance.

HSH - Volume knob, 5 way selector

Thicker in the midline of the body, maybe 7 cm, with contoured wings (tapered back to maybe 2 cm), a bit like the ESP Vulture

Hey, just came out of a massive guitar hunt over the past year or so. Our prefs differ .

I agree with you on the custom guitars $$$
Crazy, however not all factory guitars are the same. Ibanez prestige (Japan) are fantastic.
Their Indonesia as well.

ESP ( E-II Japan) is also great and they make a series of V style guitars.

Check out Kessell

Ola Englund makes some cool guitars.

You have to spend $1500 - 2.3 to get a great factory guitar imo.

Charvel is an exception, but you dont seem like an SS guy.

2 Likes

https://www.espguitars.com/products/20983-e-ii-arrow?category_id=1965182-arrow-series-guitars

Need to reposition the lower strap button, if that is even possible due to the placement of the output jack, and replace the active pickups with passive. So it will need about $400 of work from the start. Not great.


Set neck thickens considerably around the 15th fret. I’d like more higher fret access.

I couldn’t find anything on Kessell guitars.

Perhaps KIESEL guitars were meant.

1 Like

Possibly he meant Kiesel guitars. They look quite good, but the short body that Jeff seems to prefer won’t work for me. I’d love if they made a headless V.

Chatting the Kiesel on Facebook now.

Why do I get so fired up about buying gutiars? I guess because most guitar designs are terrible for me.

Steinberger spirit meets all your needs. Depends if you like the look tho.
In my opinion getting the head off feels great…

That has an even shorter body than the Keisel.

I want the guitar to be more left-shifted, to make it easier to access the higher frets with my left hand. My unusually broad shoulders and flat breastplate provide a challenge for upper fret access.

I would try any guitar I can find around or return ship for free. But I’m more inclined towards the V shape because you can use the tips of the V to position the guitar for solos.

Why don’t you like the short body?
More of you to see ;p

I have one and have zero issues with holding the guitar. It actually for me becomes preferable to a big bodied guitar. But different blokes, different strokes.

Edit, oh ok I understand, dave mustaine style. The small body is light enough to move around quite a lot for me.

KIESEL guitars yes.

Also Schecter makes a V style… evil twin?

I think that the ESP could still work…
That lower button/input jack shouldn’t be an issue, and you dont have to swap out EMGs immediately.

I drove myself crazy over my recent guitar purchases. It’s very much a personal thing, but I’m a SS guy. Ibanez Prestige and Yngwie Strat…

Just got an ESP , LP variant

2 Likes

They do :star_struck:!

I am looking into that.

But the body is so short. See the LP above; longer body style. That’s necesssary to get the guitar more left-shifted. This kiesel guitar has the body too short. Even for the X Series, they took the Carvin V220 and perverted the body design by making the body right side smaller, thereby right-shifting the guitar to cause difficulty playing upper frets.

Carvin classic shape, better balanced design.

Kiesel recycled mod. Notice how they shortened the body RHS, so the strap button is nearer to the bridge.

It does look smaller! Wow. Wonder why Jeff went with this?
Just curious why does a smaller body not work well for you? I’ve always concentrated on the fretboard as the most important part of a guitar’s playability.

I’m on the hunt for a vader on reverb and ran into this a while back, looks pretty slick.

If the neck joint on the solar V is anything like the one on my S series Solar then it would be the best V neck joint ever. Fret access has always been my problem with Vs I love em but past the 17th fret the access is always tricky. Rhoads Vs suffer from this badly in my experience because they were designed for 22 frets. This is a main reason I gave up on the V quest and went with super strats. The only other guess is an Alexi Laiho ESP model but the nice ones are pricey and they only have a bridge pickup.

As for Kiesel changing shapes I know there was a lawsuit or threats of one awhile back by Jackson iirc in regards to their V and X designs. Although the X shape change may have more to do with trying to compete with strandberg since lots of these modern shred dudes are into the smaller bodied guitars.

The problem is that the guitar is too right-shifted for me. The problem is worse when the strap button is at or near the bridge.

This is not unlike my bicycle seat being too high for you.

With cycling, a fit specialist will adjust the bicycle to the cyclist’s body. This includes changing the heights and angles of the seat, seatpost, stem, and handlebars.

Bicycle fit specialists make adjustments to make the cyclist more comfortable on the bike, to eliminate arm, back, neck, knee, and hip pain, and to improve efficiency, speed, comfort, and power.

In contrast, guitar players get to pick a body design and a color.

This works well for most players, as the instrument can be moved around. But when you have very broad shoulders, as I do, or a very flat breastplate, as I also do, and very long arms (I don’t have this “problem”, unfortunately), the guitar fit can be a problem.

Fit problems can also arise for smaller people, such as young children, who may be too small to play certain things on their instrument well or at all. This is also a problem with the piano.

The problem with custom instruments is aggregated with the unknown effect that any particular cut might not be easily recut. Some things, like strap buttons, can be moved. Other things, like the angle or shape of the body or the pitch of the neck cannot be easily or heavily changed once built. Once the custom guitar has been built, it’s built. If it doesn’t balance like you guessed it might, too bad. You’re stuck with a weird guitar that doesn’t balance well. Happy expensive experiment. Better luck next time.

1 Like

I was excited when I hear Kiesel would be making the X-Series. Then, when I saw it, I was instantly disappointed by the way they totally fouled it up, apparently on purpose.

Let me ask you this…
Have you ever just spent hours in a guitar shop trying out model after model?

I assume u did and arrived at the V shape?

Played superstrats for years. Tried many models and shapes.

The most comfortable guitar shape I played was the ESP Vulture (pictured above). Despite being all mahogany, it’s very light.

Good:
Contour cutaway on the body gives more room for the arm.
Light.
Guitar is left-shifted.

Bad:
The volume knobs are too far down and there are two of them.
The fingerboard is too narrow.
Large James Hetfield identifying logo.

I also purchased a Jackson Rhoads V and played that for a while. Horrible sounding high-output guitar that wouldn’t stay in tune. Fingerboard was too narrow. Action a bit high, even for me. Returned to GC.

When I see that Kiesel body shape, I want to cut off the upper horn and glue it to where the strap button is on the lower horn. I would put the strap button where the neck meets the body around the 19th fret. Such modifications would be unstable, expensive, and would require a lot of care to make it look less ugly.

1 Like